The outcome of the summative evaluation is considered as a boosting factor when its positive. What are some disadvantages of portfolio assessment. Similarly, reeves 2000 suggests three main strategies to integrate alternative assessment into online learning settings. Two trends surfaced from the feedback that the teachers offered. The important thing to clarify is what is the purpose of the assessment and then select the method. Methodology the present research aims at identifying, based on students feedback, the most relevant characteristics of the portfolio as an assessment method, in terms of advantages and disadvantages and person assessed. Early childhood portfolios as a tool for enhancing learning during the transition to school sally peters, carol hartley, pat rogers, jemma smith and margaret carr. Ensure that you allow for flexibility however, for summativeshowcase portfolios, you might have to include strict guidelines for organization ensure that students have access to resources to construct portfolios e. Teacher observations provide information that other means of evaluation do not. There are advantages and disadvantages to both structured portfolios and to more openended portfolios. While the portfolios themselves have value, particularly in the area of assessment permitting the evaluation of a wide range of outcomes and documenting growth over time, it is the process of creation that offers great power to.
Teachers have many considerations when planning tasks and assessments. Researchers and educators use the term performancebased. The use of portfolio to assess students performance eric. Portfolio assessment is also a systematic collection of student work and related.
Portfolio assessment offers a variety of benefits, including. They provide institutions with authentic assessments of student learning and promote the deeper learning that we want for our students. After collecting the data, six themes were constituted regarding the teachers opinions about portfolio use concerning portfolio conception, advantages, disadvantages and challenges of portfolios, the content of early childhood. For example, a pdf portfolio can include text documents, email messages, spreadsheets, cad drawings, and powerpoint presentations. While the use of portfolios at mangere bridge kindergarten began as a formative assessment tool for teachers and children, over the course of several years they have come to. Serves as a concrete vehicle for communication, providing ongoing communication or exchanges of information among those involved in assessment. When choosing assessment activities, it is important to take into consideration the increasingly diverse students background and variety is important to cater for learners difference. The research presented in this article attempts to capture the views of teachers of elementary education about the advantages, disadvantages, difficulties and obstacles in the application of the portal as a rating and selfevaluation tool by the. The benefits of developing a professional portfolio. For example, the evaluator can observe the interactions between the teacher and his students to determine whether the teacher has established rapport, treats students with respect and addresses questions effectively. Grant wiggins, says that authentic assessments directly examine student performance on worthy intellectual tasks, present the student with tasks found in the best instructional activities and real life and determine whether the student can craft polished, thorough and justifiable answers, performances or products.
Oracle white paperthe benefits of risk assessment for projects, portfolios, and businesses figure 9. Advantages and disadvantages of various assessment. Abstractearly childhood n 10 and firstgrade teachers n 10 views concerning portfolio usage were investigated in the current research. A portfolio is a collection of a persons work product that demonstrates his expertise and accomplishments in a particular field or area. The advantages and disadvantages of project portfolio. The pros and cons of assessing students through portfolios. Further, to exploit portfolio assessment method effectively some suggestions were made. From matriculation through graduation, the goals for expected. Strengths of portfolio assessment measures students ability over time done by teacher and student. Pros and cons of tools for doing assessment based on.
A record of a childs ongoing development over time. Teachers should convey to students the purpose of the portfolio, what constitutes quality work and how the portfolio is graded. Wednesday, january 31, 2018 portfolio tools below is an infogaphic we designed for the post we published earlier titled 5 of the best tools to create digital portfolios in class. The original files retain their individual identities but are assembled into one pdf. With the help of summative evaluation results, trainers and instructors. The use of learning portfolios, as a new approach to the evaluation process has. Disadvantages of diagnostic assessments may include a teacher making incorrect assumptions.
The advantages and disadvantages of portfolio based assessment are discussed and the parameters, guidelines, and the necessary conditions for implementing a portfolio based assessment process are examined. One of the first researchers to use the term authentic assessment, dr. Also, portfolio assessment method is compared with traditional one in terms of different aspects. First, good portfolio assessment takes an enormous amount of teacher time and. A pdf portfolio contains multiple files assembled into an integrated pdf unit. The files in a pdf portfolio can be in a wide range of file types created in different applications. The pros and cons of assessing students through portfolios instructional approaches on k12 education have changed with the passage of time. In summary, the physical educators advocated, use your assessments to document that students are learning in your classes. There are a variety of methods that can be used for assessment of, for and as learning.
The usefulness of portfolios as assessment tools in higher. Advantages and disadvantages open textbooks for hong kong. Portfolios offer students tangible evidence to show their. The net effect may be to increase or reduce the project cost. There are many different assessment activities used in higher education. A portfolio assessment demonstrates learning over the course of time rather than what a student knows a particular day. This paper defines portfolio as a selfassessment and selfreflection tool with its various types.
Recommendations for establishing portfolios as an essential component in a. This chapter describes four types of alternative assessment that might meet the needs of vocational educators and summarizes assessments in use in the cases selected for our study. A wellexecuted e portfolio program is an incredible tool for higher education. The use of portfolio to assess students performance. The chapter concludes with a brief discussion of the advantages and disadvantages of different types of as sessment. What are the advantages of authentic assessment over. Adding and deleting add or remove files easily, without having to find and select all the pages that originated in that file. Summative evaluation advantages and disadvantages wisestep.
Portfolio assessment can hold students accountable for mastering content standards in a subject area. The usefulness of portfolios as assessment tools in higher education. What are the advantages or disadvantages of portfolio. Describe the advantages of portfolio assessment for students. It should be noted that the benefits of portfolios result principally from the process of building and using them.
As an alternate assessment strategy, the portfolio provides students with the opportunity to select a progression of work to demonstrate knowledge of a topic. I dont understand why more institutions arent using them. There are several advantages and disadvantages of project portfolio management so its importantfadvantage to understand if this is the right process for your organization before making a move. Portfolios with prescribed structures are evident in programmes leading to a pro fessional qualification or an academic award where the portfolio forms part of the. Advantages of portfolio assessment students know their own weaknesses individualized instruction emphasis on the entire learning process rather than just a onetime performance portfolio not only. Advantages and disadvantages of 14 types of assessment. Portfolios can include projects, written essays, visual art projects, photography or creations made electronically. Also, using assessment within their teaching addresses district and state standards. First, good portfolio assessment takes an enormous amount of teacher time and organization. Portfolios used well in classrooms have several advantages. Other arguments against using portfolios to objectively judge the student bodys learning curve is that portfolios show. For each candidate to benefit from such ongoing assessment, his or her portfolio supervisor must. The benefits of risk assessment on projects, portfolios.
Obvious benefits of a portfolio the lesson planimagine that you apply for a teaching position at a preschool. However, there are some major disadvantages of portfolio use. Traditional assessment also has both advantages and disadvantages when it comes to the way educators teach. Portfolios have many benefits and challenges for teachers who are considering them. The pros and cons of an assessment portfolio blogger. When deciding which activity to be used, both the intended learning outcomes and the learning activities need to be. Assessment portfolios require students to continuously reflect and perform selfevaluations of their work. Challenges of using portfolio assessment as an alternative assessment method for teaching english in indonesian schools article pdf available october 2017 with 3,063 reads how we measure reads. A portfolio assessment provides an opportunity for a student to reflect on their learning, to self assess, and to formulate a deeper understanding of the concepts they are learning beyond a simple surface explanation.
With this type of evaluation, confidence is boosted and also they act as a springboard to certain behavior change at a workplace or institution. Educators strive to use various types of authentic assessments with their students. Advantages of using portfolio assessment sewell serves as a crosssection lens, providing a basis for future analysis and planning. The pros and cons of an assessment portfolio a portfolio is a collection of work, accumulated over a period of time. Advantages and disadvantages of various assessment methods 1. Advantages of diagnostic assessments include a teachers gaining valuable information about her students baseline level of knowledge about a subject, and the students may also benefit from gaining familiarity with the questions they will be asked in the summative assessment at the end of that unit. The time is needed to help students understand the purpose and structure of the portfolio, decide which work samples to collect, and to self reflect. Technological advancements have brought into play greater use of visual aids, hypermedia, and interactive simulations and lesser practice of the traditional chalkboard method. Davis and ponnamperuma 2005, for example, hold that portfolios, as a method of learning and assessment, can enhance critical thinking, learner responsibility, interaction between tutor and student, reflection and selfassessment, creativity, as well as professional and personal improvements.
The visual is too long to be included in the original post so we decided to publish it separately. The purpose and definition of 10 educational assessments. Portfolios may highlight student individual strengths and. The target postmitigation curve includes the cost of implementing the response. Below is a list of pros and cons and some common challenges cited by many classroom teachers who have successfully integrated portfolios into their classrooms. Pdf challenges of using portfolio assessment as an. The benefits of developing a professional portfolio cherylpriest what curriculum styles are you most familiar with, and which. Reduces or eliminates faculty time demands in instrument development and grading.
Portfolios contain examples of childrens work at different time periods in a school year. Selfevaluations advantages of portfolio assessment promoting student. One type of assessment is the portfolio, and this lesson describes what a portfolio is, what goes in it, and how. Additionally, when a portfolio is used by a student to selfaccess their strengths, a lack of a standard ensures that a wide range of diverse results will be produced. The use of portfolio as an assessment tool international journal.
Mittler, new directions for community colleges, number 88, winter 1994, pp. Depending on the circumstances, pdf portfolios offer several advantages over merging multiple files into a single pdf. The benefits of eportfolios for students and faculty in. Describe the advantages of portfolio assessment for.
These insights, along with samples of childrens work, can be used to create valuable portfolios. Application portfolio management apm solutions, such as oracle s primavera portfolio. Augmented by gloria rogers rosehulman institute of technology with engineering. Standardized exams commercial advantages convenient can be adopted and implemented quickly.
415 688 547 929 1562 1216 1433 1273 216 744 430 901 1342 721 157 110 1043 21 6 1485 521 764 734 1451 1316 1119 551